Simply, the decline of consociational democracy in the netherlands since the 1960s was an indicator of its success, not its failure. Lijphart democratic political systems types cases causes. International journal of peace studies, volume 14, number 2, autumnwinter 2009. Consociational democracy in deeply divided society. Political scientists and others turn to world politics to stay on top of the latest theoretical developments in the field. The consolidation of the consociational democracy in lebanon. Consociationalism is a form of democracy which seeks to regulate the sharing of power in a state that comprises diverse societies distinct ethnic, religious, political, national or linguistic groups, by allocating these groups collective rights. Skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Since world war ii a wide variety of approaches, methods, and concpts have been. The aim is to understand whether there is a democratic solution to the conflict through power sharing democracy. Czechoslovakia was a consociational democracy from 1989 until its partition in 1993.
Arend lijpharts 1969 article on consociational democracy was a compelling critique of prevailing theories of democratic stability and the launching pad for one of the most widely. Thus, switzerland has been characterized as a consociational democracy since 1943, belgium after world war i, austria from 1945 to 1966, and the netherlands from 1917 to 1967. While it may be difficult to achieve and maintain stable democratic governments in countries with deep religious, ideological, linguistic, cultural, or ethnic cleavages, lijphart argues that it is not at all. Recent advances in consociational theory luther and deschouwer, 1999 have elaborated on the crucial role of segmental parties in consociational democracy. In particular, consider his 1977 book, democracy in plural societies. View consociational democracy research papers on academia. Lijphart is the primary advocate of the consensus consociational approach.
Where consociationalism has ended, it often did so not because of its failure but. The search for political stability and democracy in the former ottoman territories has focused on political and constitutional. Through the analysis of political systems in six continents, he demonstrates that what he calls consociational democracy can be successful in severely divided or plural societies. Arend lijphart s 1969 article on consociational democracy was a compelling critique of prevailing theories of democratic stability and the launching pad for one of the most widely regarded research programs in contemporary comparative politics. Which is to say, a system of government that enshrines the basic principle that leaders should be elected by those they rule, and that decisions of the governing bodies should be reached by majority vote. This paper examines consociational theory, primarily as developed by arend lijphart,1 and its relevance in the context of plurinational places. While it may be difficult to achieve and maintain stable democratic governments in countries with deep religious, ideological, linguistic, cultural, or ethnic cleavages, lijphart argues that it is not at all impossible. Power sharing and selfgovernance in consociational theory in the middle of the 19th century, the liberal philosopher john stuart mill in his considerations on representative government expressed skepticism with regard to the possibility of democracy zin. The bestresearched book on democracy in the world today. The first is assimilationwhich is likely to happen if one large group forms the majority in a majoritarian e. Lijphart argues that consensus democracy is better see below. Power sharing and selfgovernance in consociational theory in the middle of the 19th century, the liberal philosopher john stuart mill in his. The challenges to democracy in lebanon by micheline germanos ghattas a dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the.
Political accommodation is achieved by cooperation among the elites of segmental parties that each represents a single segment of society. The political stability of the consociational democracies must be explained in terms of. Consociationalism is a form of power sharing in a democracy. That the elites have the ability to accommodate the divergent interests and demands of the subcultures. I thought it was approachable and relatively wellwritten.
Types, cases, causes and consequences by arend lijphart introduction this article is an elaboration on the typology of democratic political systems proposed in his book. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. For a brilliant, wideranging examination of the arguments set forth by advocates and critics of consociationalism, see brendan oleary, debating consociational politics. Nov 26, 2007 arend lijphart is one of the world s leading and most influential political scientists whose work has had a profound impact on the study of democracy and comparative politics. Collection the limits of consociationalismas a method of conflict management.
Modern political democracy is a system of governance in which rulers are held accountable for their actions in the public realm by citizens, acting indirectly through the competition and cooperation of their elected representatives. In the late 1960s the standard model of democratic systems was the anglosaxon majoritarian or westminster type andeweg 2000, 514. Consociational democracy as a tool for conflict resolution in plural societies. This requires that they have the ability to transcend cleavages and to join in a common effort with the elites of rival subcultures. Reexamining federalism and consociationalism as constitutional and political arrangements for community conflicts in post ottoman lands directed by nicos peristianis yucel vural university of nicosia, cyprus eastern mediterranean university, turkey peristianis.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading. After a successful decade of enforcing consociational democracy in the 1950s, it was no longer necessary for the leaders to practice consociationalism in order to hold the dutch subcultures together. There is not too much jargon and lingo being thrown around which a beginner like me appreciated. The political crisis that started in 2007 is to be explained by the diverging party politics and future ambitions of the. Abstract consociational democracy as the goal and a tool in mitigating conflict in the third world has been frequently used during the last decades, especially in subsaharan africa.
Corporate consociationalism predetermines power positions among ethnic and sectarian national groups, such as pre. In todays world, the protection of individual rights in terms of negative liberty. Modern political democracy is a system of governance in which rulers are held accountable for their actions in the public realm by citizens, acting indirectly through the competition and cooperation of. Preface to the second edition i welcome the opportunity to publish an updated edition of pat terns of democracy, originally published in 1999, because it gives me an opportunity to test whether my main. The reasons and events of the 19751995 war are still being sorted out and only history will clear that up. The analysis of favourable factors for establishment and maintenance of consociational democracy is important to assess the probability of success for consociational model in diverse societies. This chapter contrasts the classic consociationalism of arend lijphart with the revisionist consociationalism of john mcgarry and brendan oleary. Which is to say, a system of government that enshrines the basic principle that leaders should be elected by those they rule, and that decisions of the governing. Failed consociational attempts in northern ireland will be described in the third chapter.
The consolidation of the consociational democracy in. Yale university press, 1977 political science 248 pages. Consociational democracy and the case of switzerland. Can we say today that the consociational democracy in lebanon is consolidated. While his power sharing model has been widely criticized, it is also being adopted in countries as diverse as the netherlands, india, austria, south africa, and malaysia. The fourth chapter will deal with the political sustainability of the consociational. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading patterns of democracy. Consociational democracy world politics cambridge core. Consociationalism has been an influential theory on the academic study of the northern ireland peace process. Keefes fine, searching book shows that the political agreement formally resolving.
Project muse lijphart, lakatos, and consociationalism. Lijphart, consociational democracy, world politics, vol 21, nr. Consociational democracy can be found in countries that are deeply divided into. Arend lijphart is the author of patterns of democracy 3. Arend lijphart is one of the worlds leading and most influential political scientists whose work has had a profound impact on the study of democracy and comparative politics. Problems of consociationalism from the netherlands to macedonia. Patterns of democracy is a foundational work in politics, especially comparative, and it was one of the most helpful books i invested in for my first term of politics at university. Lijphart, lakatos, and consociationalism world politics. Arend lijphart has defined consociational democracy as a government by elite cartel designed to turn a democracy with a fragmented political culture into a stable democracy 5. Political parties in consociational democracy routledgeecpr studies in european political science book 7 kindle edition by kris deschouwer, kurt richard luther. Arend lijphart is one of the world s leading and most influential political scientists whose work has had a profound impact on the study of democracy and comparative politics. Pluralism and democracy in the netherlands arend lijphart, professor of political science arend lijphart university of california press, 1975 social science 231 pages. Political scientists define a consociational state as one which has major internal divisions along ethnic, religious, or linguistic lines, with none of the divisions large enough to form a majority group, but which remains stable due to. In this earlier book, he emphasized consociational democracy as a solution for states where traditional majoritarian democracy might not work due to deep ethnic, linguistic, or religious cleavages.
The article looks at the legacy of consociationalism in lebanon with the. Christian historical union class cleavages consensus countries. Here, once again, arend lijphart is directing our attention to matters which will surely engage much of the attention of students of comparative politics in the next decade. After a successful decade of enforcing consociational democracy in the 1950s, it was no longer necessary for the leaders to practice consociationalism in order to hold the dutch subcultures. The aim is to understand whether there is a democratic.
Pdf examining the favourable factors for consociational. Pdf consociational democracy in theory and practice. Nationalist partition and international intervention. Examining the favourable factors for consociational democracy. Problems of consociationalism from the netherlands to. Majoritarian democracy, nonmajoritarian or powersharing democracy, consociational democracy, consensus democracy, grand coalition. Political scientists define a consociational state as one which has major. Thinking about democracy draws on a lifetimes experience of research and publication in this area and collects together for the first time his most significant and. Lijphart says that there are three ways to solve the political problems of a divided society without destroying democracy. The political crisis that started in 2007 is to be explained by the diverging party politics and future ambitions of the proindependence and liberal new flemish alliance flanders and the pro. Consociationalism is a form of democracy which seeks to regulate the sharing of power in a state that comprises diverse societies distinct ethnic, religious, political, national or linguistic groups. Thus this chapter clarifies the research strategy chosen for this investigation. Here, once again, arend lijphart is directing our attention to matters which will surely engage much of the attention of students of comparative politics in the next. However, in various countries, such as lebanon and iraq, consociational democracy has yielded corporate forms of power sharing that have been referred to as.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The views expressed in this book are those of the author alone. The article pays tribute to professor arend lijphart, pioneer in the studies of democracy. Integrative from pol s 6 at university of california, santa barbara. This books message to the political leaders of plural societies is to. Patterns of democracy kindle edition by lijphart, arend. Consociational democracy as a tool for conflict resolution in. Consociational democracy by arend lijphart summary. Buy consociational democracy in multiethnic societies by patrick bolte isbn. Arend lijphart is known for his works on comparative methods,1 electoral systems,2 and nonmajoritarian or powersharing democracy. Consociational parties and political accommodation in. Arend lijphart is best known for his theory of consociational or power sharing democracy, which enables the peaceful governance of deeply divided societies.
Consociational democracy as a tool for conflict resolution. This chapter contrasts the classic consociationalism of arend. The author is indebted to the institute of international studies, berkeley, for financial support. Belgium and canada as crucial tests by adrien elleboudt submitted to central european.
Consociationalist theory served initially as an explanation of political stability in a few deeply divided european democracies. Yale university press books may be purchased in quantity for educational, business, or promotional use. By fragmented political culture, lijphart refers to societies that are divided by sharp. See his other works to appreciate the development of this theme. The end result of this corporate consociational division of power has been a self perpetuating capture of the state by a political sectarian elite that both lacks national accountability and undermines government commitment to the public good. Reexamining federalism and consociationalism as constitutional and political. We use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. May 26, 2008 arend lijphart is best known for his theory of consociational or power sharing democracy, which enables the peaceful governance of deeply divided societies. Parliamentary consociational democracy is designed to avoid sectarian conflicts and seeks to faithfully represent societys demographic composi tion particularly in regard to religious and. The limits of consociationalism as a method of conflict.
1112 53 530 829 840 17 230 914 77 892 408 867 146 148 478 334 523 1281 721 1216 1410 1286 1006 76 1525 551 1035 781 1047 808 1365 1327 755 1119 1210 357 231 1281 933